Rating the Best Mushroom Coffee We’ve Tried

In a world increasingly attuned to health and wellness, the journey for healthier alternatives to our cherished morning rituals has brought an intriguing contender into the limelight: mushroom coffee. This innovative beverage, blending the familiar warmth and aroma of traditional coffee with the nuanced benefits of medicinal mushrooms, is capturing the curiosity and taste buds of health-conscious consumers globally.

Why this sudden surge in popularity? The answer lies in a growing awareness of the need for wellness-focused lifestyles and the desire for beverages that do more than just wake us up. Mushroom coffee, with its promise of enhanced focus, immune support, and potential stress relief, is ticking all these boxes. It’s a unique fusion that respects the ritual of coffee while offering a nutritional upgrade.

In our quest to find the best mushroom coffee, we tried five of the best brands on the market. Each brand brings its own blend of quality ingredients and unique qualities to the table, offering a range of options for every palate and wellness goal. From the smooth, rich flavors to the carefully sourced, health-boosting mushrooms, we’re uncovering what makes these coffees stand out in a crowded field of alternatives. 

Mushroom Coffee Benefits & Overview

Most of us think of mushrooms on pizza or in pasta, but rarely as a drink. So, what’s the point of sipping on shrooms, anyway? Here’s a quick highlight of what to expect.

Is Mushroom Coffee Good for You?

Mushroom coffee isn’t just a trendy drink; it’s a health-boosting powerhouse. Rich in antioxidants and packed with functional ingredients like adaptogenic mushrooms, it offers benefits that go beyond your typical cup of coffee. These mushrooms, like Lion’s Mane and Chaga, are known for their cognitive and immune-boosting properties, making mushroom coffee a beverage that not only wakes you up but also supports overall well-being.

What Does Mushroom Coffee Taste Like?

If you’re imagining a cup of coffee that tastes like a bowl of mushrooms, think again. Mushroom coffee typically has a smooth, rich flavor, often enhanced by the earthy notes of the mushrooms. While some blends might have a more pronounced mushroom taste, many are surprisingly similar to regular coffee, making them an easy switch for coffee enthusiasts.

Pros and Cons of Mushroom Coffee

The benefits of mushroom coffee are plentiful, including enhanced focus, immune support, and potentially fewer jitters than regular coffee. However, it’s important to consider the cons. Some might find the taste slightly different, and the cost can be higher than traditional coffee. Additionally, those with mushroom allergies should obviously steer clear.

Does Mushroom Coffee Have Caffeine?

Yes, most mushroom coffees contain caffeine, but typically in lower amounts than regular coffee. This makes it a great choice for those looking to reduce their caffeine intake without giving up coffee entirely.

Mushroom Coffee vs Regular Coffee

Mushroom coffee sets itself apart from regular coffee with its added health benefits. While it offers the familiar caffeine kick, it also provides the nutritional perks of mushrooms. The result is often a more balanced energy boost without the sharp highs and lows of traditional coffee.

Decaf Mushroom Coffee

For those sensitive to caffeine, decaf mushroom coffee is an excellent alternative. It retains the health benefits of the mushrooms while completely eliminating caffeine, making it a soothing option for any time of the day. This was a bit tougher to find in the market, but there is always the option of brewing your own decaf coffee and investing in some good powdered mushrooms to blend in.

Best Mushroom Coffee Brands

We’ve got everything you need to know about the top 5 mushroom coffees. From price to flavor, ingredients, and caffeine content—here’s the rundown on the top mushroom coffee brands.

Everyday Dose

Price: Current promotion at $0.90 per cup, regularly $36 for 30 servings

Caffeine Content: 39 mg

Why We Like It:

• Uses 100% fruiting bodies
• Blends well without sediment
• Contains low amounts of caffeine

Everyday Dose Mushroom Coffee Ingredients:

• Lion’s Mane
• Chaga
• Coffee Extract
• Collagen Protein
• L-Theanine

Everyday Dose reinvents coffee by combining low-acidity, low-caffeine coffee with Lion’s Mane and Chaga mushrooms, plus collagen for creaminess. This blend offers the full-bodied flavor of traditional coffee with chocolatey notes minus the crash, jitters, and digestive issues. Focused on efficacy, it uses high-quality mushroom extracts to enhance energy, focus, mood, sleep, gut health, and immunity. 

It tastes like a mellow, smooth cup of coffee with hints of earthy nuttiness. Excellent with frothed milk and sweetener if that’s your sort of thing. Yet, for black coffee drinkers, Everyday Dose still hits the mark. 

Where to Buy: Shop Everyday Dose and Get 5 Free Travel Packs

MUD/WTR :rise Cacao

Price: $1.33 per serving if you subscribe, $1.57 for a one-time purchase.

Caffeine Content: 35mg

Why We Like It:

• Delicious chocolate and chai flavor combo
• Made with all organic ingredients
• Tastes great solo, no creamer or sweetener needed

MUD/WTR Mushroom Coffee Ingredients:

• Chaga
• Reishi
• Lion’s Mane
• Cordyceps
• Cacao
• Chai spice blend
• Black tea powder
• Himalayan pink salt

MUD/WTR is one of the OG mushroom coffee brands. It’s a game-changer for those looking to cut down on coffee who prefer something more than your average cuppa joe. It’s a blend of organic cacao, ayurvedic herbs, and functional mushrooms, and it’s big on flavor. As the website states, it “tastes like your mug of hot cocoa met a chai latte and they had a baby.” 

With only about 35mg of caffeine in their :rise Cacao, it’s a low-caffeine alternative that keeps you energized without the usual coffee jitters or sleep issues. It’s a super thick drink, which is part of the appeal but also tends to have a bit of sentiment at the bottom of the cup. Definitely a good idea to swirl towards the bottom to make sure you get all of that organic mushroom coffee goodness.

Where to Buy: Shop MUD/WTR Mushroom Coffee

RYZE

Price: Current promotion at $0.90 per cup, regularly $36 for 30 servings

Caffeine Content: 48mg

Why We Like It:

• All organic ingredients
• Fully recyclable packaging
• Coconut milk and MCT oil add extra creaminess

RYZE Mushroom Coffee Ingredients:

• Cordyceps
• Reishi
• Lion’s Mane
• Turkey Tail
• King Trumpet
• Shiitake
• Arabica coffee
• Coconut milk
• MCT oil

RYZE mushroom coffee is infused with adaptogenic mushrooms that promise not just a caffeine kick but a holistic wellness experience. It’s designed for those seeking calmer energy, sharper focus, and immune support—a trifecta for a balanced body and clear mind. Our team found it to be an excellent pick-me-up, especially during long editing sessions.

Taste-wise, RYZE is a little less coffee-flavored and more mushroom-y. Yet, it’s smooth and creamy but definitely benefits from creamer and sweetener. With less than half the caffeine content of standard coffee, it’s a perfect solution for those who love their daily cup but could do without the jittery aftermath or mid-afternoon crash. However, if you’re used to bold, black coffee, this might taste a little light to you, but using less water will remedy that.

Where to Buy: Shop RYZE Mushroom Coffee and score 15% off with code ‘RS15’

Jibby

Price: Current promotion at $1.33 per cup, regularly $50 for 30 servings

Caffeine Content: 50mg

Why We Like It:

• Organic and Fair Trade certified
• Ashwagandha is a powerful adaptogen
• Acacia fiber is a bonus for gut health

Jibby Mushroom Coffee Ingredients:

• Grass-fed collagen
• Arabica coffee
• MCT oil powder
• Ashwagandha
• Lion’s Mane
• Turkey Tail
• Acacia fiber

Jibby’s mushroom coffee offers a unique taste experience. It’s smooth and rich without the typical earthy profile of mushroom coffees. This blend stands out for its creamy texture and depth of flavor that’s sure to please even the most particular coffee aficionados. It dissolves well into water, so there are no mushrooms left behind at the bottom of your mug.

In terms of effects, Jibby delivers more than just a caffeine buzz. It’s infused with adaptogenic ingredients that work together to enhance energy levels, cognitive function, and immune support. The collagen addition is a boon for skin health, making this coffee not just a treat for the taste buds but also a nourishing choice for the body.

Where to Buy: Shop Jibby Mushroom Coffee and score 15% off with code ‘REALITY15’

Renude

Price: $1.66 per serving, or score 10% off when you subscribe

Caffeine Content: Zero

Why We Like It:

• Uses 100% fruiting bodies
• A nice caffeine-free option
• Delicious hot or cold

Renude Mushroom Coffee Ingredients:

• Wild foraged Chaga
• Peruvian cacao
• Ceylon cinnamon
• Monk fruit sweetener

Renude’s Chagaccino is a unique addition to our mushroom coffee list. This sugar-free, vegan, keto-friendly mushroom mocha mix transforms your regular coffee into a wellness drink. It’s packed with adaptogens to boost immunity, energy, and anti-aging benefits. Think of it as a healthier, tastier version of a mocha frappuccino—like sipping on coffee ice cream. 

But here’s the thing—it’s caffeine (and coffee) free. Which is a bonus if you’re looking for the benefits of mushrooms without the coffee. Yet, Renude pitches its product as the perfect addition to a cup of coffee or espresso, so you can get creative. They recommend trying hot or cold, and if you prefer to skip coffee, just mix it into a milk or plant-based milk of your choice.  

Where to Buy: Shop Renude Mushroom Coffee

Four Sigmatic Organic Coffee

Price: $1.58 per cup, with gradual discounts for multiple bags or subscribe & save

Caffeine Content: 65mg

Why We Like It:

• Organic ingredients
• Multiple tiers of buying options
• Additional adaptogens

Four Sigmatic Mushroom Coffee Ingredients: 

• Medium roast instant coffee
• Lion’s Mane
• Chaga
• Rhodiola
• Ashwagandha
• Mucuna

Four Sigmatic produces a wide range of mushroom coffee supplements and drink mixes. When reviewing their best-selling organic mushroom coffee, we found it to be a really great mix of adaptogenic ingredients. Ashwagandha and Rhodiola offer additional health benefits alongside the medicinal mushrooms to create a hyper-focused brew for energy and mental clarity.

When mixing this drink, be sure to use a milk frother thoroughly, as the powder is a bit difficult to fully mix with the water. We found a bit of sediment at the bottom of the cup. As for flavor, Four Sigmatic’s coffee is very earthy and definitely benefits from creamer and sweetener. We like frothed half & half with honey and a sprinkle of cinnamon and sea salt.

Where to Buy: Shop Four Sigmatic Mushroom Coffee

Embracing the Mushroom Coffee Trend

In exploring the burgeoning world of mushroom coffee, it’s clear that this innovative drink is more than just a trend; it’s a healthful twist on traditional coffee rituals. Each brand we’ve sampled, from Everyday Dose to Four Sigmatic, offers unique blends that cater to a variety of tastes and wellness needs. 

Embracing mushroom coffee is about more than just savoring a new flavor—let this new ritual become a commitment to a lifestyle that values wellness, energy balance, and mindful consumption. This emerging coffee culture, blending the familiar with the medicinal, is a reflection of our evolving priorities toward health and wellness.

mushroom investing

Read More